COMFY FLATS — OR PASSION KILLERS?

SHE SAYS: These brogues make me feel trendy, youthful and definitely put a spring in my step. The comfort factor is off-the-scale wonderful. I feel ready for whatever the day throws at me and there is something undeniably sexy about wearing such manly shoes. The fact that they’re so masculine and clumpy makes me feel incredibly feminine. I also love the little jacket, which adds a bit of attitude. These would work as well on a date night as they would for shopping with the girls.

HE SAYS: At first glance, I thought she’d stolen my work shoes. I am actually a big fan of flats and can never understand how or why my wife tortures herself in heels, but these brogues are just too masculine, inelegant and stompy. They have no place on a woman’s foot. This outfit would look so much better with some knee-high boots.